Hubble and Webb disagree over Hubble tension

Hubble and Webb disagree over Hubble tension

[ad_1]

There’s one thing incorrect with our understanding of the Universe and, because the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) has confirmed, it doesn’t appear to be an observational error. 

One of many greatest mysteries in cosmology is the ‘Hubble stress’, the puzzle that the expansion of the Universe we see in the present day doesn’t match what we predict it ought to be from wanting on the early cosmos.

Utilizing observations of the earliest Universe and making use of our understanding of how area behaves, astronomers can calculate the worth of enlargement we look forward to finding in trendy instances. 

Illustration of the expansion of the Universe. Understanding more about this phenomenon could reveal clues as to how the Universe will end. Credit: Mark Garlick / Science Photo Library
Illustration of the enlargement of the Universe. Understanding extra about this phenomenon may reveal clues as to how the Universe will finish. Credit score: Mark Garlick / Science Picture Library

They will additionally immediately measure the present enlargement utilizing ‘commonplace candles’, objects whose identified intrinsic brightness permits us to calculate their distance.

Nevertheless, when the enlargement values of the early and late Universe are in contrast, the 2 are discovered to be stubbornly completely different. 

It was thought that an observational error may very well be skewing the outcomes.

The Hubble Space Telescope has spent 30 years observing commonplace candles, however the telescope’s decision means close by stars usually overlap in observations, whereas cosmic mud confuses the outcomes.

JWST’s infrared eyes see by this mud and its greater decision means the candles are a lot clearer.

A earlier JWST examine in 2023 confirmed that Hubble’s measurements of normal candles referred to as Sort Ia supernovae have been right.

Image of galaxy NGC 5468, 130 million lightyears from Earth, combining data from the Hubble and James Webb space telescopes. It's the farthest galaxy in which Hubble identified Cepheid variable stars, markers for measuring the expansion rate of the universe. Credit: NASA, ESA, CSA, STScI, Adam G. Riess (JHU, STScI)
Picture of galaxy NGC 5468, 130 million lightyears from Earth, combining knowledge from the Hubble and James Webb area telescopes. It is the farthest galaxy by which Hubble recognized Cepheid variable stars, markers for measuring the enlargement fee of the universe. Credit score: NASA, ESA, CSA, STScI, Adam G. Riess (JHU, STScI)

Now this new examine has verified the outcomes that Hubble received utilizing Cepheid variable stars (corresponding to these in NGC 5468, above), commonplace candles used to take measurements nearer to Earth.

“We’ve now spanned the entire vary of what Hubble noticed, and we will rule out a measurement error as the reason for the Hubble stress with very excessive confidence,” says Adam Riess from Johns Hopkins College in Baltimore, who led the examine. 

“What stays is the true and thrilling risk we now have misunderstood the Universe. We have to discover out if we’re lacking one thing on find out how to join the start of the Universe and the current day.”

These 36 galaxies imaged by Hubble play host to both Cepheid variables and supernovae used to measure the Universe’s expansion
These 36 galaxies imaged by Hubble play host to each Cepheid variables and supernovae used to measure the Universe’s enlargement. Credit score: NASA, ESA, Adam G. Riess (STScI, JHU)

Why the Hubble stress is so vital

The Hubble stress, removed from inflicting complications, is thrilling.

A disagreement about one thing as elementary because the pace of enlargement supplies a hope that some massive breakthrough to resolve it’s not far away.

Possibly it’s. However the truth that we name it a ‘stress’ – not argument, monumental downside or embarrassment – displays that evaluating native measurements with the early Universe is tough.

Historical past exhibits that astronomers measuring the enlargement have sometimes been overconfident. If that’s taking place once more, there could also be no stress in any respect.

Till somebody finds an error with our errors, although, we will go on dreaming of recent physics.

This text appeared within the Might 2024 situation of BBC Sky at Evening Journal.

author

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *